Home Law & Justice

Supreme Court Refuses Trump’s Appeal Defending DEI Grant Cuts at the University of California

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the Trump administration's appeal over research grants it cut at the University of California, which leaves in place a Ninth Circuit ruling that the cuts likely violated the First Amendment.

Two researchers in a sunlit university laboratory, one holding a printed letter while the other looks on

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the Trump administration’s appeal over research grants it cut at the University of California, which leaves in place a Ninth Circuit ruling that the cuts likely violated the First Amendment. Granting a petition takes four justices, so the Solicitor General’s request to defend firing researchers over their viewpoint did not find them.

Early coverage of the denial, including NBC’s, treats the keyword searches as something researchers alleged. The agencies’ own sworn declarations describe the searches, and the question the government put to the Court assumes viewpoint was weighed.

What the government asked

The petition’s question was whether the First Amendment bars the government “from considering the viewpoints furthered by academic research projects when deciding whether to grant or terminate funding.”

Its answer: the First Amendment “does not prohibit the government from declining to award competitive grants that fund research projects that promote DEI.”

What the agencies swore

In declarations the district court quotes in its June 2025 order, the National Science Foundation’s acting director said grants were picked using “keyword searches and analytics.”

The National Endowment for the Humanities’ acting chair said staff scored open grants on spreadsheets from “High, Medium, Low, or No Connection” to the executive orders.

Read the two columns together. The government did not tell the Supreme Court that nobody weighed viewpoint. It told the Court it was allowed to.

We think that is the heart of it, and it is why the Ninth Circuit’s conclusion holds up: the agencies “made the decisions to terminate based only on the recipients’ perceived expression of DEI, DEIA, or environmental justice viewpoints,” and a termination aimed at suppressing a viewpoint “likely violates the First Amendment.”

We read the Court’s Nov. 16 order list for what it says about this petition. No. 26-210 sits in the plain “certiorari denied” block, with no noted dissent and no recusal.

The same list shows what a recorded disagreement looks like. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented from the denial in a California medical-education case, Justice Gorsuch noted he would have granted it, and Thomas wrote a separate statement on Maryland’s gun-carry limits.

Nobody wrote a word on Thakur. A justice does not have to note a dissent, so silence is not proof of unanimity, but no one used the chance to say they wanted this case.

A Berkeley Historian Got a Form Letter

Take Christine Philliou, a UC Berkeley history professor funded by the NEH. Her proposal set out to “shed light on the possibilities of inclusion and belonging of non-Muslims in a Muslim state.”

Then a form letter arrived, with no reason in it.

Judge Rita Lin found the government offered no evidence of why the named plaintiffs’ grants were cut. She concluded the record showed the grants were likely terminated because of what the researchers wrote in their applications.

You cannot answer an explanation that was never sent. You can only check which words in your own title a keyword list might have caught, and the NSF researcher in the case, Jedda Foreman, had a title that included “racial” and “equity.”

A denial is not an affirmance and sets no precedent. The Court gave no reasons.

The Ninth Circuit’s ruling is also preliminary. It affirmed the injunction only for the class of researchers cut because of DEI, and it reversed for the class that got form letters, because claims to recover grant money belong in the Court of Federal Claims.

That second half follows the Court’s own August 2025 order letting NIH cuts proceed, which Reuters notes rested on procedure and not the First Amendment. So the justices have not said these grants are protected. They have declined to say the Ninth Circuit was wrong.

How much money is at stake?

Two figures are circulating and both are in the record. The government’s petition says the NSF and NEH grants at issue had about $59 million remaining when terminated, with expiration dates as late as November 2029. The $324 million NBC reports matches the plaintiffs’ tally of everything cut at UC from Jan. 20 to early June 2025 across agencies, per their brief opposing review.

Can the agencies cut these grants again?

The plaintiffs’ law firm says the NSF, NEH, NIH, Defense and Transportation agreed not to re-terminate the grants “while any Supreme Court proceedings are pending.” Those proceedings ended Monday. We have not seen the stipulation’s text, so we cannot say what replaces that promise, but the injunction the Ninth Circuit affirmed is still in force.

What happens next in the case?

It returns to Judge Lin in San Francisco, where briefing on summary judgment and class certification for most claims was paused until the Court acted. A related appeal over grants from Defense, Transportation and HHS has been held in abeyance behind this one since Dec. 3, 2025, according to the government’s petition.

The government told the country’s highest court that it may screen research by viewpoint, and the Court would not take the question up. Judge Lin’s courtroom and a Second Circuit appeal over NEH grants are where the argument goes next.