“The single most impressive video game I have ever played.” IGN, in its 10 out of 10 review of Grand Theft Auto VI
Grand Theft Auto VI holds a Metascore of 99 from 152 critics, with not one review counted as mixed or negative, and a user score of 5.6 from 89,345 ratings on the same page. The second number is the one going around this weekend, and it tells you less: those 89,345 ratings come to roughly one for every 364 copies Take-Two says it sold before launch, and Metacritic does not ask anyone to own the game before scoring it.
So the verdict is in, and it is two verdicts. One comes from people paid to finish the game. The other comes from a crowd that is mostly arguing about something else.
What the Critics Actually Said
The 99 ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the highest score Metacritic has recorded. The tie undersells it. Ocarina earned its 99 from 22 critics; GTA 6 is holding the same number across 152, which is a much harder average to keep up. Game Informer gave it 100 and called it “a monumental achievement in storytelling.” Take-Two put the 99 in the press release announcing its sales, which tells you how much the company wanted that number.
The praise is not uncritical, and the complaints line up with what players who own the game are saying. On OpenCritic’s review list, Videogiocare.it scored it 9.8 and wrote that it was “held back only by minor pacing hiccups and a locked 30 FPS.” South Korea’s Gamemeca gave it 97 and flagged “an overly lengthy introductory learning phase.” ScreenHub, at 80, found “large sections that are boring and too limited.” Read the reviews instead of the score and you get the honest version: a slow first chapter, a frame rate capped at 30 on consoles, and everything after that mostly working.
Who Is Casting the 5.6
Do the arithmetic on Metacritic’s own breakdown this morning: 44,190 positive ratings, 6,375 mixed, 38,780 negative. Positive is the largest bloc by more than 5,000. A 5.6 average out of that split does not mean most people found the game mediocre. It means one group is handing out 10s and another is handing out zeros, and the average lands in a middle almost nobody picked.
The split is also holding still while the pile grows. On Friday, GTABase counted about 67,700 ratings, 49 percent positive and 44 percent negative. Some 21,600 ratings later, positive is still 49 percent and negative has slipped to 43. Those 38,780 negative accounts equal about 0.12 percent of the 32.5 million copies sold before release, or one in roughly 838, and that assumes every one of them bought the game.
What they are saying is on the record. LevelUp collected the user reviews: “Woke garbage,” one called it, “a boyfriend simulator with good graphics.” Another said the game “shows the degradation of men and the glorification of women.” Some reviews mention bugs and the 30 FPS cap, the same things critics flagged. Many are about Lucia, the woman who shares the lead with Jason.
We think that is a campaign, not a consumer verdict, and Metacritic should treat it as one. GTABase notes the site has pulled review-bombing campaigns before. Leaving this one up as a headline number turns a grievance about a female co-lead into what looks like a quality rating, and every outlet that runs “critics and players are split” helps it along.
The Deal
Here is what the two numbers add up to. The critics are right about the game, and the honest complaints are narrow: if a locked 30 frames per second or a slow opening chapter would ruin it for you, the reviews say so plainly. If not, the 99 holds up when you read the reviews behind it, which is more than most 99s can claim.
The market has already voted. Take-Two says GTA 6 did $3.79 billion in day-one retail sales through the end of November 19, a company estimate of retail value rather than booked revenue. Grand Theft Auto V managed first-day sell-through of more than $800 million in 2013, so the new game opened at about 4.7 times its predecessor. Thirty-eight thousand Metacritic accounts hated it. Take-Two would like to introduce them to the other 32.5 million.
One more number belongs next to the 99. The craftsmanship critics are praising came from a studio that fired 31 workers in the UK, and in launch week those workers were awaiting a tribunal ruling while their former colleagues voted on a union. The reviews are a verdict on the work. The tribunal will be a verdict on how Rockstar treated some of the people who made it, and that one will outlast any user score.