Home Breaking News

After a Hung Jury in June, a Federal Jury Convicts Jonathan Rinderknecht in the Palisades Fire Arson Case

A federal jury in Los Angeles convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht on Friday of both Palisades Fire arson counts, five months after a first jury split 10-2 for acquitting him, and the coverage so far skips what changed in…

Courtroom sketch of Jonathan Rinderknecht seated at the defense table in a Los Angeles federal courtroom, with jurors in the box behind him

A federal jury in Los Angeles convicted Jonathan Rinderknecht on Friday of both Palisades Fire arson counts, five months after a first jury split 10-2 for acquitting him, and the coverage so far skips what changed in between: the same defendant, the same fire and the same theory, with a different evidence list.

  • The verdict: guilty on both counts, destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce. He had pleaded not guilty to both.
  • The jury: six men and six women, out for nearly three days.
  • The theory: a brush fire detected at 12:12 a.m. on Jan. 1, 2025 that crews put out after five to eight acres, which prosecutors say smoldered underground until Santa Ana winds revived it six days later.
  • The toll: the Los Angeles Fire Department counts 23,448 acres burned, 12 people dead and 6,837 structures destroyed.
  • Sentencing is expected March 17, 2027.

In June, prosecutors portrayed a man angry at the world. In the retrial they zeroed in on digital and forensic evidence: cellphone location data, fire-alert cameras that prosecutors said showed no one else approaching before the flames appeared, and a green barbecue lighter they said carried his DNA. The defense answer never moved. Nobody saw him light anything, no camera recorded the ignition itself, the lighter sat in the glove compartment of his rental car, and a retired arson investigator testified that hundreds of people had walked the scene before police locked it down, which he called “a case killer.”

DateEvent
Jan. 1, 2025Lachman Fire detected at 12:12 a.m.; crews put it out
Jan. 7, 2025Santa Ana winds; the Palisades Fire erupts
Jan. 31, 2025Palisades Fire fully contained
Oct. 7, 2025Rinderknecht arrested near his Florida home
Oct. 15, 2025Grand jury returns a three-count indictment
June 2026First trial ends in a mistrial, jurors 10-2 for acquittal
Nov. 20, 2026Guilty on both counts, 688 days after the Lachman Fire (our count)

What the Statute Leaves the Judge

We read the statute instead of the summaries. The two counts as reported match subsections (f)(1) and (i) of 18 U.S.C. 844, and each says the defendant “shall be imprisoned for not less than 5 years and not more than 20 years.” That is a five-year floor and a 20-year ceiling on each count, 40 years if a judge ran them back to back, against the 45 reported at the October 2025 indictment, when a third count, timber set afire, was in the case. Both provisions add harsher terms where injury or death results. None of the verdict reports says jurors were asked to find that.

We think the conviction answers who started the first fire and nothing else. The government’s own theory is that a blaze crews had put out stayed alive underground for six days, and a criminal trial is not built to ask what should have been done in those six days. That question belongs to the city, and this verdict does not close it.

Sentencing is expected March 17, 2027, and the statute leaves the judge one decision it does not make: how far above five years each count goes, and whether the two run together.