The Venezuela oil deal “makes the Strait of Hormuz a nonfactor for the Western Hemisphere.”
The tell was how he got there. Pete Hegseth left Miami on an Air Force jet with no reporters aboard, the Pentagon issued no notice of the trip, and Venezuelan state television broadcast him greeting interim president Delcy Rodriguez before the Pentagon had acknowledged he had left. Hours later, at the U.S. Embassy in Caracas, the defense secretary announced a military cooperation pact and then said the line above, AP reported. It is a claim with a unit in it, and the unit is barrels. We did the arithmetic he skipped: every barrel of oil Venezuela exported last month adds up to about 5 percent of what moved through Hormuz before the Iran war.
The Arithmetic Hegseth Skipped
What Hegseth Said
Nov. 18, Caracas: the oil deal “makes the Strait of Hormuz a nonfactor for the Western Hemisphere.”
March, with Hormuz shipping largely halted: “we have been dealing with it; don’t need to worry about it.”
What the Barrels Say
- Hormuz flows: 21.6 million barrels a day before the war, 4.9 million in the second quarter, a loss of 16.7 million.
- Venezuela’s October exports, all products: 1.08 million a day.
- 1.08 divided by 21.6 is 5.0 percent of the pre-war flow.
- 1.08 divided by 16.7 is 6.5 percent of what was lost.
- Even the deal’s 1.5 million goal, all of it new and exported, is 9.0 percent of the loss.
The Energy Information Administration put flows through the strait at 21.6 million barrels a day in the last quarter of 2025, before the war, and 4.9 million in the second quarter of this year, which means Hormuz has lost about 16.7 million barrels a day. Venezuela’s oil exports were 1.08 million barrels a day in October, according to shipping data seen by Reuters, which also says growth has plateaued. The most generous reading available is the 1.5 million barrels a day that Rodriguez said the bilateral project is after; treat every one of those barrels as new and exported, and it still covers 9 percent of the loss. The comparison is imperfect, because Hormuz carries crude and liquids and Venezuela’s cargoes are a different mix. No correction closes a gap that wide.
Hegseth has also made this kind of call before. In March he told reporters not to worry about the strait while shipping through it was largely halted. Eight months on, with flows down 77 percent from their pre-war level, the line has been upgraded from “don’t worry” to “nonfactor,” and the proposed fix is a country whose oil industry, Air & Space Forces Magazine notes, will take years to restore.
The Pump Does Not Agree
The hemisphere’s biggest oil consumer is the test. AAA said on Nov. 12 that the national average for regular gasoline was $3.91, against $3.08 a year earlier, an increase of 83 cents, or about 27 percent, and that the month was so far the most expensive November on record for gas prices. AAA credits recent declines to falling crude and cheaper winter-blend fuel and does not mention Hormuz, and we are not claiming it blames the strait. The point is narrower. A nonfactor leaves no fingerprint, and a hemisphere that was truly insulated from the strait would not be paying 27 percent more at the pump after a quarter in which the strait carried less than a quarter of its usual flow. AP itself noted that the Iran war has raised gasoline prices and contributed to Republican losses in this month’s midterms. That is what a factor looks like.
A Pact Nobody Has Read
The oil line is the part that can be checked. The rest cannot, because nothing has been published. Neither government has said what the agreement requires, on what timeline or with what money, Euronews noted, and AP reported that Hegseth offered few specifics beyond “training together, partnering together, sharing intelligence.” He did say Venezuela had gone from “our most aggressive regional threat to a compliant security partner,” and he said it to a government whose court-allowed term expired in July and which still has no election date, AP reports. AP also notes that at least 240 people have been killed in the administration’s boat strikes since September 2025, with little evidence released that the vessels carried drugs.
We think a defense pact with a government that holds power because the United States removed its predecessor should come with a text, and Congress should demand it, along with the legal basis for the intelligence sharing. We also think “compliant” is the most honest word in the speech. The oil side is no clearer: AP says the owner of North American Blue Energy Partners, the company the U.S. government made the oil deal with, sat in the audience, and our earlier look found Washington had bought 55 percent of a joint venture, not 65 billion barrels of American oil.
Hormuz is a factor. The pact is a secret. Both were announced with confidence and without numbers.