Sean Cairncross, the national cyber director, is out after six tech outages in six days, and the reporting now offers at least four different reasons why. We lined them up against the outages themselves and found that the explanation everyone is implying, that he took the fall for the failures, is the one the administration’s own account of the failures rules out. Every one of the six was blamed on something inside the operator’s own house, and none on an attacker. That leaves a country whose two senior civilian cyber jobs are both in limbo, and a White House that has explained itself only through anonymous officials.
Four Accounts of One Exit
A White House official confirmed Thursday that Cairncross is leaving, and Kirsten Davies, the Pentagon’s chief information officer, will fill the job in an acting capacity, NBC News reported. Past that point the accounts split, and they are worth reading side by side because each one comes from a different set of sources.
- Axios broke the story, and iHeartRadio’s summary of it says he is leaving to give the White House time to win Senate confirmation of a successor before Democrats take control in January, and that he did not want to serve another two years.
- CBS News reported that he was fired, citing multiple sources, and that chief of staff Stephen Miller, who took over from Susie Wiles earlier this month, had long wanted him gone because he did not think Cairncross had the expertise for the job.
- A White House official told The Hill he was let go, that President Trump supported it, and that Trump believed Cairncross lacked the proper cyber credentials. The Hill’s own headline says he was fired.
- NBC News framed the exit as coming in the wake of the outages, and most coverage did the same, though that rests on timing alone. None of the sourcing above says the outages are why.
Three of the four are about people and politics. Only the fourth touches the outages, and it is about the calendar, not cause. It is also the version most readers will walk away with.
Six Outages, Six Stated Causes
Between Thursday, November 12 and Tuesday, November 17, six systems failed. We built the ledger below from company statements, officials’ testimony and the reporting linked here, and sorted each by who owns the system.
- Nov. 12, Microsoft (private). A global Microsoft 365 outage. Stated cause: a hidden flaw in a July patch to its gateway servers, which Microsoft executive Charles Lamanna said left them overloaded under heavier demand and lower capacity.
- Nov. 13, FAA (federal, through a contractor). A ground stop of more than four hours. Stated cause: a newly installed router flooded the network while a contractor swapped copper lines for fiber.
- Nov. 16, JPMorgan Chase (private). Online banking failures that spilled over to other banks. Stated cause: a software bug in hardware systems at its own facilities.
- Nov. 16, United Airlines (private). About an hour of downtime. Stated cause: an internal technology issue.
- Nov. 17, National Security Agency (federal). Its classified internal network degraded. Stated cause: scheduled routine maintenance.
- Nov. 17, Apple (private). Apple Pay and iCloud breakdowns. Stated cause: an internal update.
Count the owners and the picture is plain: four of the six systems belong to private companies and two to the federal government. Count the causes and it is plainer still. All six were attributed to something inside the operator’s own house, and four of them, Microsoft, the FAA’s contractor, the NSA and Apple, to a patch, an update or a hardware swap. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told the House Homeland Security Committee on Wednesday that what officials have seen over the last ten days is not an orchestrated attack by a foreign malign actor, and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia said there was “no indication whatsoever” of malicious cyber activity in any of them. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said he was “98 percent confident” the week had nothing to do with adversaries. Sen. Josh Hawley, a Republican, was less comfortable, telling reporters that if it is all a coincidence it is “like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world.”
What the Job Does Not Include
CBS describes the Office of the National Cyber Director as the body that advises the president on cybersecurity and coordinates strategy across the federal government. It does not run Microsoft’s gateway servers, Chase’s data centers, United’s reservation systems or Apple’s update pipeline, and it did not configure the router at the FAA’s remote site. Even at the two federal systems it is a policy office rather than the operator. So the outage reason fails by the administration’s own testimony. If the outages were operator failures during maintenance, the people who answer for them are the operators. If instead an adversary was involved, the White House dropped its top cyber official in the middle of an investigation, which is worse. We think blaming him for the week would be scapegoating, and the officials who spent Wednesday insisting nothing malicious happened have made the case for us.
The Credentials Reason Has a Date Problem
The reason The Hill’s source gave, that Cairncross lacked the proper cyber credentials, is the only one with a paper trail, and the paper trail points back at the White House. The Register noted in February 2025, when Politico reported Trump’s plan to nominate him, that this was a lawyer whose career ran through Covington and Burling, Republican National Committee counsel jobs and the Millennium Challenge Corporation, with no direct experience in the role. That résumé has not changed since. We are not defending the choice, because the office needed someone who could read a root-cause report as well as sign one, and that was knowable from the day his name surfaced. But a reason that was equally true on the day of the nomination is not a reason for a dismissal in the third week of November. It is a label for one. The Hill also relays earlier Axios reporting that allies of Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent argued Cairncross had not been urgent enough on AI questions, which is a reason with a date earlier than any outage.
Two Top Cyber Jobs, Neither Settled
Davies, who runs information technology for the Pentagon, will serve as acting director of an office whose head needs Senate confirmation, and CBS notes the administration has only a narrow window before the Senate turns Democratic in January. On the same Thursday the news broke, Michael LoSapio, Trump’s nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency and Palantir’s chief information security officer, ducked questions about who won the 2020 election and told Sen. Richard Blumenthal he did not believe January 6 was an attack. Republican Thom Tillis and Democrat Ron Wyden plan to hold his nomination, according to The Hill’s account of Politico’s reporting. Put those together and the country’s two senior civilian cyber jobs, after a week in which the NSA’s classified network, the air traffic system and the largest bank all stumbled, are an acting appointee and a nominee facing a hold from both parties.
What Should Happen Next
The White House should say on the record which of the four reasons is the real one, because it cannot be all four and only the outage version would make the next failure somebody else’s fault. The president should name a permanent director this week and the Senate should hold hearings in the lame duck, since the confirmation math only gets worse once the majority changes. And the paperwork behind the week should be public: Microsoft owes its final report today, the FAA’s router is at L3Harris for diagnostic testing, and the NSA has not said how its patch failed. As we wrote on Tuesday, the three failures share a shape, and the fix is bulkheads: limits on how much traffic one component can push, changes rolled out to a slice before the whole, and recovery systems that check the destination is healthy before sending it the problem. None of that needs a new name on the door. All of it needs someone with the standing to demand it, and as of Thursday night that person is acting.