Home Business

After a 10-2 Vote to Hold Rates, Fed Minutes Show Almost Every Official Expects More Hikes

Minutes of the Federal Reserve's October meeting, released Wednesday, show a committee that held interest rates steady and expects to raise them. The vote was 10-2 to hold the federal funds range at 3.75% to 4%. Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack voted for a quarter-point hike.

Generated image of a couple at a sunlit kitchen table going over a mortgage statement, a laptop and a calculator

Minutes of the Federal Reserve’s October meeting, released Wednesday, show a committee that held interest rates steady and expects to raise them.

  • The vote was 10-2 to hold the federal funds range at 3.75% to 4%. Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack voted for a quarter-point hike.
  • “Almost all participants” judged that “further action to raise the target range” would likely be appropriate.
  • “A couple” said a move of more than 25 basis points “could warrant consideration” at the Dec. 8-9 meeting if inflation data disappoint.
  • Staff put September inflation at 3.6% by the Fed’s preferred PCE measure, and 3.1% once food and energy are removed.
  • “Almost all participants” discussed the risk that returns on AI investment disappoint, and “most” noted that AI-related debt had grown through “complex and opaque financing structures.”

The Hold Came With a Condition

The 10-2 vote reads as a pause, and the minutes say it was not one. Some participants wanted a quarter-point increase on the spot, judging the stance “not sufficiently restrictive,” and a few warned that waiting risked “a larger and more disruptive tightening later.” Others said they could have backed no change “provided that it was clearly understood by market participants that further tightening was likely.” That is a hold granted on the understanding that nobody mistakes it for relief. The committee raised rates in September to this range, and October reads as a stop on the way up.

The Arithmetic Behind “Not Sufficiently Restrictive”

The range has a midpoint of 3.875%. Staff estimated September PCE inflation at 3.6%, so the policy rate sits 0.275 points above it, about 0.3. Against core PCE at 3.1% the cushion is 0.775, about 0.8. Those are our figures, a crude trailing comparison that the Fed does not use to define “restrictive,” but they show why the hawks call the stance loose. Households feel the consumer price index rather than PCE, and our own estimate of October CPI was about 4.0%, which puts the midpoint 0.1 points below it. The minutes themselves flag “an unusual discrepancy between CPI and PCE inflation rates.”

What the Minutes Name and What They Do Not

By our count, whole-word matches in the text of the minutes page, “AI” appears 36 times in roughly 6,300 words and “energy” 11 times. “Iran” appears once, in a sentence from the markets briefing about “the ongoing conflict with Iran.” The word “war” does not appear. The vast majority of participants “noted that high energy prices continued to contribute to current inflation pressures,” and staff attributed September’s readings to “earlier tariff increases, higher energy price inflation,” and AI-related goods prices. The institution will not name the cause of the energy bill. We will: gasoline was up 27.4% on the year when we checked in September, the Iran war is why, and the administration owns both the war and the tariffs.

The AI Passage Nobody Is Quoting

Coverage has stressed that “many participants viewed the AI buildout as a material source of inflation risk,” and that staff worried about “off-balance-sheet leasing commitments and circular financing arrangements among AI-related firms” that “could amplify losses if returns on AI investment were to disappoint.” A few sentences after the inflation-risk line, the minutes say something that changes the picture: “A number of participants remarked that greater scrutiny of the sector’s returns and financing could lead to a slowing in AI-related spending, thereby tending to reduce inflation pressures.” Put plainly, some of the officials raising rates count an AI pullback as one of the ways inflation comes down. The same document calls the debt behind that spending “opaque.”

Where the Hikes Already Land

A majority of participants noted a tightening in financial conditions since September, citing “higher mortgage interest rates” along with wider credit spreads for higher-risk and AI-related borrowers. Many said higher borrowing costs and more selective lending “had weighed somewhat on residential investment, CRE, small business borrowing, and some other interest-sensitive sectors.” In plain terms, the tightening is already in the price of a mortgage and the cost of a small-business loan, before the next hike arrives.

December Is Priced, the Size Is Not

Market pricing described in the minutes assigned “high probabilities” to a quarter-point hike by year-end and two more by the summer of 2027. The median respondent to the New York Fed’s Desk survey expected a hike in December and another in March 2027, followed by a cut early in 2028. A quarter-point in December would take the range to 4% to 4.25%. A half-point, one version of the larger move a couple of participants floated, would take it to 4.25% to 4.5%.

What We Think

The inflation this committee is fighting comes first from tariffs and energy, by the staff’s own ordering, and those are the administration’s to answer for. The instrument being used against it lands on mortgage borrowers and small businesses, and the Fed cannot say so out loud. The AI half is the one to watch: officials are raising rates into a debt-financed buildout they call opaque while counting on it to slow by itself, which is a hope rather than a plan. When Democrats take over Congress in January, the first question it puts to the Fed should be how much of the December hike is a bill for the war.