The version everyone knows: the tech billionaires bought themselves a president.
What doesn’t fit: in 2024 Peter Thiel said he would not give money to Trump’s super PAC. His biggest check had gone out two years earlier, to one Senate race.
On November 3, Ohio voters gave that Senate seat to a Democrat. Sherrod Brown beat Republican Jon Husted for the term JD Vance won in 2022, the race Thiel backed with $15 million, a record for a single Senate contest. Vance held the seat for two years before moving up to the vice presidency. By our arithmetic, that is $7.5 million for each year of Senator Vance. The seat is gone now. The vice president is not, and that is the part of the purchase still paying out.
What the Money Bought, in Order
- 2009. Thiel writes that he no longer believes “freedom and democracy are compatible.”
- 2016. He takes the stage at the Republican convention and urges Americans to vote for Donald Trump.
- 2020. The Sovereign Individual, a 1997 book predicting that microprocessing will “subvert and destroy the nation-state,” is reissued with a new preface by Peter Thiel.
- 2022. $15 million behind Vance in Ohio.
- 2025. Vance is sworn in as vice president.
- 2026. Democrats win the House and flip the Senate, Ohio included, and Jensen Huang resigns from Nvidia, months after joining Trump’s trip to Beijing.
Read that list as a prophecy and an investment plan. The writer Gil Duran said it on Jon Stewart’s show this week: these men are driven by profit, and also by prophecy. The prophecy says the nation-state ends. The investment buys the people who run it in the meantime, and an exit for when it does. Thiel got his New Zealand citizenship in 2011 after 12 days in the country.
Here is what we think. None of it was hidden, and as far as anyone has shown, all of it was legal. That is the problem. The midterms took back one seat. They did not take back the access, the contracts or the passport, and the money that bought them is still there for the next race. The same week one router in Arkansas helped ground every U.S. flight, Duran asked the obvious question: if the system is that fragile, imagine what a gang of apocalyptic billionaires can do.
Every source in the episode
- Thiel, Palantir chairman (Palantir board page)
- $15M for Vance (CBS News)
- A record, per Politico (Fortune)
- Brown flips Vance's old seat (AP via OPB)
- Democrats flip the House and Senate (CNBC)
- Huang resigns (NBC News)
- Board won't reinstate Huang (NPR)
- No money for the super PAC (CNBC)
- The Sovereign Individual, Thiel preface (Simon & Schuster)
- Born to Win (The New Yorker)
- The Stanford Review (Fortune)
- The Diversity Myth (NYRB)
- Sacks, AI and crypto czar (CNBC)
- X.com, Confinity and the honeymoon (Fortune)
- eBay buys PayPal (SEC filing)
- The $5 billion Roth (ProPublica)
- SpaceX's first outside money (Via Satellite)
- SpaceX nearly ran out of money (CNBC)
- Palantir's name (The Ringer)
- In-Q-Tel (Fortune)
- ICE's $30M deal (Business Insider)
- Q3 revenue +96% (Fortune)
- Thiel and Gawker (NYT via CNBC)
- Gawker bankrupt (CBS / AP)
- "Freedom and democracy" (Cato Unbound)
- Vance and Thiel (CNBC)
- Vance's fund (Bloomberg)
- "Fire every single mid-level bureaucrat" (Defense One)
- Rubio briefing (NYT via SF Examiner)
- Megaspeed blacklist (AFP via NZ Herald)
- Megaspeed denial (Bloomberg via The Edge)
- 12 days in New Zealand (RNZ)
- Seasteading (Wired)
- Thiel and Patri Friedman (Bloomberg Businessweek)
- Prospera's $1.63B claim (ICSID via italaw)
- Trump in Manila (NPR)
- 99-year lease (The Next Web)
- Antichrist lectures (Fortune)
- Arkansas router (The Hill)
- Clip: Interesting Times with Ross Douthat (The New York Times)
- Clip: The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart, Nov 17, 2026